UK's Supreme Court Rules Against Mastercard, Visa In Retailers' Fees Battle

By Donna Ahern
UK's Supreme Court Rules Against Mastercard, Visa In Retailers' Fees Battle

Britain's highest court has upheld an earlier Court of Appeal ruling that credit card companies Visa and Mastercard restricted competition in the way they set fees for retailers, opening the way for them to seek compensation.

The case, which dates back to 1992, was brought by retailers Sainsbury's, Morrisons, Asda and Argos and relates to the charges Visa and Mastercard levy on the retailers when cardholders make a transaction – so called default multilateral interchange fees (MIFs).

The UK Supreme Court upheld the finding of the Court of Appeal in July 2018 that the MIFs charged within the Visa and MasterCard payment card schemes was an unlawful restriction of both European Union and UK competition law.

The ruling means the retailers can proceed to a trial to decide compensation.

Morgan Lewis partner Frances Murphy, the lead counsel for Sainsbury’s, said retailers could potentially receive billions of pounds in damages.


"Sainsbury’s will now be seeking to recover the full amount of the unlawful charges it has incurred," Murphy said.

'Swift Resolution Of The Matter'

Kate Pollock, head of competition litigation at Stewarts, which represented Morrisons, Asda and Argos, said her clients "look forward to a swift resolution of the matter without further delay.”

However, Mastercard said the Supreme Court’s decision was not a final ruling and there will be further court hearings to determine the key issues raised.

It said these hearings will most likely not take place until 2021.

"We continue to firmly believe that retailers of all sizes derive real value from our network," it said.


Visa said it was 'disappointed that the Supreme Court did not agree with the previous High Court ruling that Visa’s UK interchange complies with competition law.'

'Visa supports the decision to send the matter to a specialist tribunal so that the evidence can be properly considered,' it added.

News by Reuters, edited by Checkout. Click subscribe to sign up for the Checkout print edition.

Stay Connected With Our Weekly Newsletter

Processing your request...

Thanks! please check your email to confirm your subscription.